In the fall of 2019, students at a middle school in the South Bronx received their class schedules. They compared which classes they had, who their teachers were, and how hard or easy they expected the class to be. “She’s dope, but he’s basic,” I overheard one say. Students at the school regularly struggled to pass the state literacy tests. Teachers said it was because the students were disproportionately impoverished, had special learning needs, or were learning English. Sometimes all three.
On one student’s schedule, I spied a class called Humanities. My heart raced. It was a double-block, meaning the school intended to integrate English and social studies into one interdisciplinary class meeting twice the time. When middle and high schools do humanities classes well, it is a sight to behold. Picture it. You read Sandra Cisneros’ The House on Mango Street while comparing its narrator’s experience to the oral histories of Mexican-Americans in Chicago. You study great speeches in Shakespeare and use what you learned to analyze oratory at the 1787 Constitutional Convention. You read books from The Odyssey, study life in Ancient Greece, and pen a critique of Christopher Nolan’s film adaptation. You unpack the literary elements of Amanda Gorman’s “The Hill We Climb” while tracing her allusions to the past, present, and future of the Black experience. I eagerly visited the Humanities classroom to witness the wonder of true interdisciplinary inquiry.
That is not what I saw. Rather, I saw something far more unsettling than I fully appreciated at the time. It was Humanities class in name only. In truth, the class was a crafty effort by the school’s administration to do something I have come to call literacy-maxxing.
What is Literacy-maxxing?
Literacy-maxxing is when a school’s approach to literacy skill development compromises students’ well-roundedness, emotional well-being, and civic-mindedness. It is often accompanied by a reduction in class time for other subjects as schools borrow time wherever they can find it for more literacy instruction. Whether it’s to increase test scores or to comply with new policies centered around the science of reading, literacy-maxxing appears to be alive and well in the nation’s schools.
To be clear, foundational literacy is an essential skill set that all schools must deliver for students. It is the skill set that unlocks all other academic disciplines. Schools must ready students to be prepared, in part, for a world that requires them to work in an age of AI, to understand medical prescriptions, to read food labels, to follow national debates, to learn about the world, and to vote. It is no wonder that education reformers have made literacy test scores the sharpened tip of the accountability movement for over two decades. Literacy scores are often considered a bellwether for learning quality in America.
If you are the kind of person who awaits test score results like you do the next Sally Rooney novel, you will know that for many years there has been quantitative cause for concern when it comes to American students’ literacy skills. Internationally, American students’ test scores have been stagnant or declining for twenty-five years. On the national stage, a biennial test has reported only thirty-one percent of fourth grade students to be proficient in literacy. In my own New York City, only half of elementary and middle school students meet the state’s proficiency level. Mind you, these downward or erratic trends follow trillions of dollars invested in education since 2001. Everywhere you look you see headlines about literacy decline, podcasts skewering teaching methods, and reports that young people and adults alike are reading less than ever.
It makes sense that literacy skill development gets center stage on policy agendas and in classrooms. It is not surprising that literacy test scores have become increasingly important to schools, that schools and districts are pouring more money into literacy intervention, and that schools under pressure to raise literacy scores are scraping any time they can find to build their students’ literacy skills. But taken together, there is a hidden cost.
The Hidden Costs of Literacy-maxxing
There are many hidden costs to literacy-maxxing that receive far too little attention these days. Allow me to share two that are most top of mind.
Students’ literacy skills suffer.
Contrary to what one might think, literacy-maxxing results in students’ literacy skills withering. This is because in the world of literacy-maxxing, literacy is defined mostly as foundational reading skills. The lessons, the tests, and the zeitgeist focus on foundational reading alone, removed from most authentic contexts, at the expense of the fuller spectrum of 21st century literacy: speaking, listening, note-taking, annotation, writing, video production, audio production, visual forms of thinking, acting, music production, news media analysis, debate, and so much more. The field watches the test scores, which are overwhelmingly driven by reading, without considering that the tests do not measure what they are believed to measure: namely literacy. Even students who do well on such tests can arrive at college having never read full novels, be unsure how to communicate with professors and peers, and struggle to write well and deeply. Of course AI appeals to them. Not because they are lazy. But because their K-12 schools didn’t prepare them sufficiently for the glorious wonders of real speaking, listening, reading, and writing as their states promised.
English class gets slowly erased.
The discipline where literacy, fully defined, gets taught has been English class for over a century. In the wake of literacy-maxxing, more and more English teachers are under pressure to teach reading skills rather than the full continuum of literacy.
Take literature.
Teaching literature has been a subject of research for at least a century. When students are taught how to read full-length texts, they learn how to engage in deeper analysis (and enjoyment) of a work as they analyze how an author’s micro decisions at the sentence level weave together to create something bigger and more sophisticated at the macro level. Beautiful, even. Learning to read literature builds students’ sense of character and relationship to others. In fact, neuroscientists have shown this on brain scans: reading literature activates the parts of the brain associated with empathy. Not to mention learning to read literature helps students understand the complexity of the world, of human beings, of relationships, and of politics.
Literacy-maxxers, however, tend to consider reading full-length books an unaffordable luxury. The closest they get is excerpts from books that are aligned to discrete skills and can quantitatively demonstrate evidence of skill mastery. (Sounds inspiring.) In this model, too few students build intellectual endurance. Too few students learn to identify with the experiences of characters because, well, the texts they receive are by definition just fleeting clips. Too few students learn to enjoy the pleasures of entering into imaginary worlds that safely yet electrifyingly teach them about life’s contradictions. They might be able to read, but they are not readers.
Now: writing.
If literacy-maxxing had one archetypal victim it would be the teaching of writing. The teaching of writing gets little attention these days in education policy and practice alike. It is understandable why. In addition to making room for teaching reading skills in precious class time, writing is not a skill assessed on standardized tests with any seriousness. In New York, state tests limit writing assessment to some soulless responses to text excerpts and, when longer opportunities to write appear, they are formulaic and humdrum.
When taught well, however, writing is an academic and civic superpower. Researchers have demonstrated, for instance, that writing instruction deepens students’ reading skills as well. It makes sense when you think about it: you can teach a student to read without writing, but you can’t teach a student to write without reading as well. With instructional time so limited, you would think this kind of literacy two-for-one would appeal to more schools. Perhaps more importantly, teaching writing gives students the skills they need to have voice and agency in the world. To paraphrase literacy professor Ernest Morrell in a lecture I attended years ago, when you teach young people to read but not to write, you are teaching them systematically to “listen and shut up.”
Young people who can listen and read in order to discuss and debate great ideas; young people who can write sustained and compelling papers or speeches or op-eds or love letters or whatever genre they want in order to better their lives and the lives of others; at a minimum, these qualities comprise what it means to be literate.
An AI Twist I Did Not See Coming
And this is the great twist of it all. As AI becomes increasingly embedded into society and schools, it is AI that is revealing just how inhuman our own education system has become. AI dazzles students because, in part, it does things that seem so fundamentally worth learning, which too many K-12 schools do not prepare young people to do: read and summarize interesting texts, create connections across bodies of knowledge, write an argument that captures something insightful, find something nuanced to talk about, even.
Critics are concerned that AI will replace students’ learning. Not me. I think we overestimate how much students are learning now. I am more concerned that policy makers and education leaders have allowed teaching and learning to become something AI can approximate at all.
Hey, Humanities!
Leaving the school one afternoon from a day of coaching, I called a friend as I walked to the elevated subway stop. Students, who just hours earlier were lifeless in the classroom, burst into shouts and laughs as they sprinted down the street, organized pickup basketball games, and bathed their faces in the Mott Haven sunlight. My friend answered. I blurted, “I think I just figured out how the humanities dies in school.”
“Really, how?”
“It’s literacy!” I declared. Literacy has become the Brutus to the humanities’ Caesar. Saruman to Gandalf. Peter Pettigrew to James and Lily Potter.
If there is any hope to reverse this dire humanistic course, it is emerging right now all around us. Put literacy in its proper place in classrooms. Stop conflating reading and literacy. Resurrect, fund, and protect true humanities education in schools for civic, artistic, and economic engagement. As AI gives the lie to the salvific promises of literacy-maxxing, we have an opportunity to reverse the slow erasure of K-12 humanities education for the sake of our children, our society, and all that is dope (not basic) in the Bronx and beyond.



